Immigration Reform 2013: Reform Will Not Solve All Problems, But It Is a Start

“Give me your tired, your poor,

Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,

The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.

Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,

I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

For generations the Statute of Liberty greeted millions of immigrants on their journey to the land of opportunity. Whether it was for life, liberty, or the pursuit of happiness, individuals throughout the world traveled to our nation in search of the American Dream. It was and is a simple dream: the promise that you will be judged on the basis of your character, and not on the basis of your race, religion, class, or creed. It is the promise that through hard work and determination you can achieve a better life for you and your family. This promise is what motivates immigrants, legal and illegal, to come to the United States. Today, it seems as though the American Dream is slipping away, but we as a nation can fight to reclaim it, and the first step is to pass immigration reform.

For those who do not believe economic inequality is increasing (and surprisingly, 58% of Americans do not), here are a few key statistics to help illustrate the gravity of our nation’s problem. Income inequality, as measured by the Gini index, has been on the rise since the start of the new millennium. Relatively stable during the 1990s boom years, the United States' Gini index has risen significantly since the Great Recession (1.6% in 2011 alone, compared to 5.2% in the prior 17 years combined). 

Our economic “recovery” exceedingly seems to benefit the richest Americans, while the poor and middle class are left behind. The top 1% received 93% of the income gains in the first year of the recovery. Poor and middle-class wage stagnation is a major reason for this. Deregulation, privatization, globalization, erosion of the social safety net, and the destruction of unions have all contributed to an economy that values corporate profits over rising middle-class wages. Corporate profits are 22% above their pre-recession levels, while employee compensation is 3% lower. The result of these trends is the dreadful fact that 80% of American adults will face joblessness or reliance on some sort of government welfare program. 

So you may be asking, what does all of this have to do with immigration reform?  Organizations from across the political spectrum, from conservatives to progressives, claim that immigration reform will benefit the American economy, and low-wage Americans in particular. Illegal immigrants and low-wage workers are in perpetual competition for jobs.  When an illegal immigrant can work for less than the federal minimum wage, this puts poor Americans at a distinct disadvantage. According to the Cato Institute, legalization of low-skilled immigrant workers would increase the U.S. GDP by 1.27%, or $180 billion, largely because immigrants are more likely to start businesses than non-immigrants. A Small Business Administration studyfound that immigrant-owned businesses tend to have higher sales and are more likely to export good and services than non-immigrant-owned businesses. 

The United States of America is a nation of immigrants that was built upon the millions of individuals who traveled here in search of a better life.  We need to change our immigration system to one that can fulfill the requirements of a 21st century economy. Reform will not solve all of our nation’s problems, but it is a start. It will renew a promise: the promise that together we all prosper, the promise of a thriving middle class, and the promise that America will always be home to the hardworking, the tired, and the poor, yearning for an opportunity to succeed.  

Investing in Growth

            The word on everyone’s mind is sequester.  Turn on the news, the radio, or pick up a magazine and you will see it.  The sequester is a series of indiscriminate spending cuts to lower our nations budget deficit.  It will cut government programs across the board; excluding entitlement spending (the true cause of our debt crisis).  Entitlement spending requires more and more of our nations budget each year and yet our leaders in Washington refuse to discuss actual reform.  President Obama has proposed to base future entitlement payments on chained-CPI, which will save a substantial amount of money.  However, this does not address the fundamental problems with Medicare and Social Security (high medical costs combined with an aging population). 

            Even better, the sequester is a manufactured crisis; a result of Washington’s inability to compromise and lead our nation out of a weak recovery.  The purpose of the sequester was to force Democrats and Republicans to work together for real reform.  Who in their right mind would allow these indiscriminate budget cuts?  Our leaders in Washington would HAVE to make a deal before the sequester comes into effect.  Once again the American people have been let down. 

            With all this talk of spending cuts, one key aspect of our recovery is lost in the noise.  Where is the discussion of growth?  How will Washington help the American economy prosper in the 21^st century?  We might be able to cut our way to lower deficits, but we cannot cut our way to more economic growth.  The best way to increase revenues and decrease our deficit is to increase the taxable base.  What better way to increase revenues, then through growth inspired policies?  The faster the economy prospers, the quicker a solution to our debt will emerge. 

            Today’s low interest rate environment puts us in a unique position to invest in our future.  With interest rates at record lows we can borrow and invest to help our nation prosper.  But we must act now!  If the FED’s minutes this week showed anything, it was the fact that interest rates will not be low forever.  Washington’s fiscal policy needs to compliment the FED’s monetary policy. 

            Now some people may argue that the government has tried and failed to steer the economy in the right direction.  They will point to the trillion dollar deficits of the past four years and failed investments in companies like Solyndra and A123.  However, I beg to differ.  Imagine what our economy would look like today if the government spent trillions on research and development, education, and infrastructure rather than bailing out big banks.  What we need today is a smarter government that invests its limited funds efficiently; not a smaller government that you can  “drown in a bathtub”. 

             Like it or not the government plays an instrumental role in steering the economy.  It is time to move beyond the ideology of how we would like our government to be and accept the reality of what government is.  Washington has played an important role in the economy for generations.  President Eisenhower, a republican, invested in America’s infrastructure and help build the interstate highway system, which revolutionized commerce in our nation.  The Apollo program provided advances in technologies ranging from kidney dialysis, to semi-conductors, to athletic shoes.  And we should never forget that the United States Military played an instrumental role in developing ARPAnet, the precursor to the Internet. 

            The American economy is revved up and ready to go; we just need Washington to clear us a path.  Will they decide for a short-term Band-Aid or real investment in our future?  Will they maintain entitlements for the older generations or provide a future for the younger generation?  It is time for millennials to make our voice heard in Washington.  Our government needs incentives to focus on long-term solutions.  It is time for us to stand up and demand a prosperous future!